I hear this every week. A client leans in — sometimes she actually whispers — and says, "Neelam, I still cook with ghee. Don't judge." As if the steel dabba of ghee in her kitchen were contraband, and her grandmother's tadka a crime.

Twenty years ago, ghee was the villain of the Indian kitchen, blamed for every heart attack in the family. Today it's a "superfood" that some people claim cures everything short of a broken heart. I'll be straight with you: both extremes are wrong. Here's what the evidence actually says.

How ghee became the villain

The 90s and 2000s were the low-fat decades. Every magazine cover screamed that fat — especially saturated fat — would clog your arteries. Ghee, which is mostly saturated fat, took the hardest hit. Middle-class kitchens swapped the ghee dabba for bottles of refined vegetable oil, and our grandmothers' cooking suddenly carried a warning label.

That advice wasn't invented out of nothing. As Harvard Health notes, saturated fat does raise LDL cholesterol, and for years the assumption was simple: saturated fat equals heart disease, full stop. But nutrition science has a habit of learning that the simple version was too simple.

What the big reviews actually say

Here's the honest version, because the internet lies about this constantly. A Cochrane review of the trials found that reducing saturated fat intake for at least two years does appear to lower the combined risk of cardiovascular events — but it found little to no effect on deaths from heart disease or deaths overall. That is a genuinely mixed picture, not a vindication and not a condemnation.

The most useful finding from the research is about replacement, not removal. Harvard researchers showed that people who swapped saturated fat for refined carbohydrates — white rice, white bread — did nothing for their heart risk. Those who swapped it for unsaturated fats or whole grains lowered it. In other words, the family that ditched ghee and started deep-frying everything in refined oil, then eating bigger plates of white rice, gained precisely nothing.

The Indian evidence is split — which is exactly the point

Studies done on Indians don't agree with each other, and I want you to see that clearly rather than hear me cherry-pick. One cross-sectional study of 200 adults in urban north India found that the group eating the most ghee and the least refined oil had the lowest history of heart disease. Interesting — but it's a snapshot, not proof, and it can't tell us whether the ghee caused the difference or whether something else about those people's lives did.

On the other side, a 2026 survey of nearly 500 Saudi adults found ghee intake significantly associated with obesity, diabetes, and cardiovascular disease — also a snapshot, also not proof. And a large ICMR-INDIAB dietary study found saturated fat intake above recommended levels in nearly every state, alongside too many refined carbs and too little protein. Nobody can look at that pattern and call it healthy.

The honest position: the dose makes the poison

So where does that leave the dabba in your kitchen? Exactly where India's own nutrition scientists put it. The 2024 ICMR-NIN dietary guidelines cap saturated fat below 7% of daily calories and keep total visible fat — all cooking oils and fats combined — to about 27 to 30 grams a day for a 2,000-calorie diet. Ghee isn't banned; it's budgeted. A spoonful in your dal tadka fits inside that budget. Drowning every sabzi, paratha, and sweet in it does not.

This is also what WHO and FAO advise globally: keep saturated fat under 10% of daily energy. Notice what neither WHO nor ICMR says: that ghee cures anything, boosts immunity, or is somehow healthier than other fats. Those claims come from marketing, not evidence. Anyone promising you ghee will fix your gut, your immunity, or your cholesterol is selling you something — probably ghee.

How I actually use ghee in my own kitchen

Practically, here's my rule: use ghee where its flavour earns its place. A teaspoon in tadka, where mustard seeds and curry leaves bloom in it and perfume the whole dal. A little on a hot bajra roti in winter. For everything else — everyday sabzi, frying, bulk cooking — I reach for mustard, groundnut, or sesame oil, and I rotate them. That way ghee is a seasoning, not a cooking medium, and the 7% cap takes care of itself.

The old wisdom got one thing right: ghee in small, deliberate amounts, inside an otherwise sensible diet of whole grains, dals, vegetables, and modest oil, never harmed anyone's grandmother. What harmed people was never the spoon of ghee. It was the spoon of ghee on top of fried snacks, sweets, white rice, and a sedentary day. Fix the pattern, keep the flavour.

Confused about what fats fit your plate and your health conditions? Fill in the questionnaire and let's build an eating plan around your kitchen — ghee dabba included, guilt not required.